دانشنامه پارس مسترزپارس مسترز ایران toastmasters.ir ↗

Project 4 of 4 • Pathways Level 1

Evaluation and Feedback

Learn to receive feedback, apply it, and give it to others.

  • پروژه
  • ⏱ Speech 1 & 2: 5–7 min · Evaluation: 2–3 min
فهرست این صفحه
Illustration for the Evaluation and Feedback project

تکلیف شما

هدف
Learn to receive feedback, apply it, and give it to others.
نمای کلی
This project has three parts: (1) deliver a 5–7 minute speech and receive feedback; (2) deliver a second 5–7 minute speech that applies that feedback — ideally evaluated by the same person; (3) evaluate a fellow member’s speech in 2–3 minutes.

Assess your skills#

Rate yourself from 1 (new to me(to 5 )I am an expert) before you begin. Return to this table when you finish the project.

مهارت‌های خود را ارزیابی کنید#

سطح مهارت فعلی خود را با امتیاز دادن به هر یک از گزاره‌های زیر (از ۱ تا ۵) ارزیابی کنید. ستون «پیش از ارائه» را اکنون و ستون «پس از ارائه» را پس از پایان پروژه کامل کنید.

  • ۵ شایان تقلید
  • ۴ بسیار خوب
  • ۳ چیره‌دست
  • ۲ رو به رشد
  • ۱ نیازمند بهبود
جدول خودارزیابی
گزارهپیش از ارائهپس از ارائه
Receiving feedback without becoming defensive
Applying feedback to improve
Observing behaviours, not personalities
Giving balanced, specific feedback
Delivering an evaluation within time

Feedback is not advice#

Advice tells a speaker what to do; feedback describes what you observed and how it affected you. Feedback is easier to accept and easier to act on.

Advice (avoid)Feedback (prefer)
“Don’t be so scared.”“I noticed that your hands were shaking.”
“You have to speak up.”“I had trouble hearing you from the back.”
“Improve your eye contact.”“I noticed you were averting your eyes.”
“Stand up straight.”“Your upper body tilted forward.”
“You didn’t move enough.”“You remained still in one place.”

Giving feedback well#

  • Use “I” messages — “I felt…”, “I noticed…” — not “you should…”.
  • Describe observed behaviour, never personality.
  • Limit criticism to two or three points; begin and end with genuine strengths.
  • One-on-one, start by asking how the speaker felt about the presentation.
  • Be specific — quote words and moments.
  • Stay within 2–3 minutes.

Activity: quick check#

#ExampleStructure
1In a one-on-one evaluation, what do you ask first??
2What kind of messages keep feedback personal and non-judgemental??
3What should feedback focus on??

How the two speeches are scored

Speech 1 is a learning speech: the evaluator identifies two or three growth opportunities. Speech 2 is evaluated with the same form plus “Applied Feedback”, showing how well the speaker used the earlier comments. Your evaluation speech is scored on Delivery and Engagement; it must be 2–3 minutes to score 3 or higher.

پارس مسترز ایران — با هم، رساتر سخن می‌گوییم.

© ۱۳۹۷ پارس مسترز ایران. تمامی حقوق محفوظ است. پارس مسترز ایران، نشان (لوگوی) پارس مسترز ایران و تمامی علائم تجاری و حقوق نشر مربوط به پارس مسترز ایران، دارایی انحصاری این سازمان است و استفاده از آن‌ها تنها با کسب اجازه مجاز است.

toastmasters.ir • docs.toastmasters.ir • کد منبع با مجوز MIT