
تکلیف شما
- هدف
- Learn to receive feedback, apply it, and give it to others.
- نمای کلی
- This project has three parts: (1) deliver a 5–7 minute speech and receive feedback; (2) deliver a second 5–7 minute speech that applies that feedback — ideally evaluated by the same person; (3) evaluate a fellow member’s speech in 2–3 minutes.
Assess your skills#
Rate yourself from 1 (new to me(to 5 )I am an expert) before you begin. Return to this table when you finish the project.
مهارتهای خود را ارزیابی کنید#
سطح مهارت فعلی خود را با امتیاز دادن به هر یک از گزارههای زیر (از ۱ تا ۵) ارزیابی کنید. ستون «پیش از ارائه» را اکنون و ستون «پس از ارائه» را پس از پایان پروژه کامل کنید.
- ۵ شایان تقلید
- ۴ بسیار خوب
- ۳ چیرهدست
- ۲ رو به رشد
- ۱ نیازمند بهبود
| گزاره | پیش از ارائه | پس از ارائه |
|---|---|---|
| Receiving feedback without becoming defensive | ||
| Applying feedback to improve | ||
| Observing behaviours, not personalities | ||
| Giving balanced, specific feedback | ||
| Delivering an evaluation within time |
Feedback is not advice#
Advice tells a speaker what to do; feedback describes what you observed and how it affected you. Feedback is easier to accept and easier to act on.
| Advice (avoid) | Feedback (prefer) |
|---|---|
| “Don’t be so scared.” | “I noticed that your hands were shaking.” |
| “You have to speak up.” | “I had trouble hearing you from the back.” |
| “Improve your eye contact.” | “I noticed you were averting your eyes.” |
| “Stand up straight.” | “Your upper body tilted forward.” |
| “You didn’t move enough.” | “You remained still in one place.” |
Giving feedback well#
- Use “I” messages — “I felt…”, “I noticed…” — not “you should…”.
- Describe observed behaviour, never personality.
- Limit criticism to two or three points; begin and end with genuine strengths.
- One-on-one, start by asking how the speaker felt about the presentation.
- Be specific — quote words and moments.
- Stay within 2–3 minutes.
Activity: quick check#
| # | Example | Structure |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | In a one-on-one evaluation, what do you ask first? | ? |
| 2 | What kind of messages keep feedback personal and non-judgemental? | ? |
| 3 | What should feedback focus on? | ? |
How the two speeches are scored
Speech 1 is a learning speech: the evaluator identifies two or three growth opportunities. Speech 2 is evaluated with the same form plus “Applied Feedback”, showing how well the speaker used the earlier comments. Your evaluation speech is scored on Delivery and Engagement; it must be 2–3 minutes to score 3 or higher.