
تکلیف شما
- هدف
- Work with a group to practise reaching consensus on any topic.
- نمای کلی
- Option 1: at a club meeting, lead a group toward consensus in 20 minutes on a challenging but achievable topic (it’s fine if you don’t reach it), then give a 2–3 minute closing statement on the experience or decision. Option 2: with VPE approval, lead a non-Toastmasters group toward consensus (invite a club member to observe if possible), give a 5–7 minute club speech about it and submit the Project Completion Form.
Assess your skills#
مهارتهای خود را ارزیابی کنید#
سطح مهارت فعلی خود را با امتیاز دادن به هر یک از گزارههای زیر (از ۱ تا ۵) ارزیابی کنید. ستون «پیش از ارائه» را اکنون و ستون «پس از ارائه» را پس از پایان پروژه کامل کنید.
- ۵ شایان تقلید
- ۴ بسیار خوب
- ۳ چیرهدست
- ۲ رو به رشد
- ۱ نیازمند بهبود
| گزاره | پیش از ارائه | پس از ارائه |
|---|---|---|
| I can gain consensus from people with differing views or needs. | ||
| I am comfortable delaying a decision until all ideas are voiced. | ||
| I can lead a group to a decision all parties accept. | ||
| I am open to feedback and ideas from all stakeholders. | ||
| I can see how this project applies to my life outside Toastmasters. |
Competencies#
- Recognise the importance of including all group members in decision making
- Commit to incorporating feedback and ideas from all stakeholders
- Create an environment where all ideas are heard
- Lead conversations to a satisfactory outcome for the group
Compromise, consensus and majority#
| Method | What it means |
|---|---|
| Consensus | Everyone builds an agreement that satisfies all, combining the wants and needs of the group |
| Compromise | Parties make concessions — e.g. Anais backs solution zeta, a teammate backs alpha, and they combine parts of both |
| Majority | The group accepts what at least half the members agree |
Seek consensus when most or all stakeholders must agree to move forward, when a group must carry out the decision, or when relationships matter as much as the decision. Its greatest benefit is everyone’s commitment to the result and cooperation in carrying it out.
Identify stakeholders#
- Internal — club members, teammates, project leads, volunteers directly affected.
- External — e.g. community members who don’t work on the project but are affected.
- Too large a group? Decide with internal stakeholders and then ask external ones for feedback, or bring representatives of both — and in either case share the decision with everyone for review.
Manage the group#
Gather feedback from others affected to form initial views and spot constraints. Decide how you will share information promptly, set expectations for communication and follow-up, and communicate every step through to implementation.
Successful consensus building#
- Brainstorm and record every idea without criticism, then narrow to the best options and weigh pros and cons objectively.
- Keep the conversation on topic and positive — a little levity helps.
- Manage conflict: no personal attacks, encourage “I” messages and listening to all sides; stop unproductive arguments and ask a disruptive member to stop, or to step away.
| Step | What to do |
|---|---|
| Discuss possibilities | Consider how each option affects each stakeholder group; weigh conflicting answers |
| Identify concerns | Track each until resolved |
| Ensure participation | Give everyone a chance to speak, not just the leader or the loudest |
| Reach consensus | Eliminate options that don’t fit; re-brainstorm as concerns arise until all agree |
| Repeat as necessary | Split the issue into smaller problems and repeat |
When consensus fails#
Without consensus a group can stagnate, or a leader may impose a decision, which risks resistance when it is carried out. A compromise may be the step that moves things forward — and deciding not to decide for now can be best: time and space often bring agreement later.
Consensus-building quiz#
| # | Question | Options |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | What best defines a compromise? | All parties must make concessions to reach agreement / All parties follow a leader’s recommendation / All agree from the start |
| 2 | Best way to manage conflict? | Limit participation / Allow off-topic time / Create respectful listening and focused discussion |
| 3 | A key part of moderating consensus building? | Discouraging unnecessary feedback / Ensuring every stakeholder can share their opinion / Reaching a solution in the first meeting |